Previous

Crash and depression

    

Why was there a Great Crash in 1929?

1. Wall Street Overheated

    •  1920s 'Boom' → high confidence; speculators sought quick profits → bolder trading → 1924-29 shares rose 5x.

    •  Share prices exceeded firm values; speculation was inflating prices.

2. Insider Trading & Corruption

    •  Unsound firms floated shares (eg a fake South American mine) /Buyers focused on profits, ignoring risks.

    •  Senate Committee found corruption & between banks & brokers.

3. Speculation

    •  600k speculators by 1929 /Poorer investors bought '' (borrowing 90% of share value).

4. Panic

    •  March & Sept 1929: Loss of confidence after predicted crash.

    •  Banks stabilized market by buying shares temporarily.

    •  24 Oct 1929: 13m shares sold in panic → prices crashed.

    •  29 Oct 1929: 16m shares sold → banks stopped intervention → total collapse.

    •  Speculators stuck with loans & worthless shares.

 

Why was there a Great Depression 1929–33?

Crash ≠ automatically cause Depression, but factors combined → economic collapse.

1. International Trade

        •   1930 Tariff → 60 retaliatory tariffs → global trade fell → US agriculture & industry damaged by shrinking exports (Hoover blamed 1931 European financial collapse).

2. Maldistribution of Wealth

    •  Top 5% owned a of the wealth (so saved not spend); yet 40% of Americans in poverty = fall in demand → price crashes.

3. Bank Failures

    •  1929 crash → speculators defaulted → 7,000 bank failures, 1929-33 (inc. 1931 ) → 400k depositors lost savings → mass withdrawals → economy starved of credit → fall in spending.

4. Underlying Economic Weaknesses

    •  1920s: coal, iron, textiles weak; agriculture overproducing; depression hit ∵ these sectors collapsed.

    •  Over-production → too many goods → low profits → job losses.

5. Gold Standard

    •  The linked the $ to US gold reserves → limited supply of money & govt spending.

    •  Countries leaving gold standard (e.g., Britain, 1931) recovered faster.

6. Great Crash

    •  Only 1.5m shareholders, 600k speculators → limited direct impact.

    •  However, the bull market had been financed by $8.5 billion in loans to speculators.

    •  When speculators → destabilized banks bank failures → economic collapse.

7. Expectations – Cycle of Depression

    •  Loss of → people saved 'just in case' → fall in spending → firms closed → job losses.

    •  1929-33: 109k companies folded → mass unemployment → fall in wages & spending → worsening recession.

Economic Theories

8. Reduced Demand (Keynes)

    •   (1936): $500m hoarded → drop in spending = key cause → firms closed, workers unemployed.

9. Economic Policies & 'The Fed' (Friedman)

    •  : Fed policies (eg raising interest rates, 1931) reduced money supply → prolonged depression.

    •  2002: Governor of the Federal Reserve admitted Fed’s failure worsened Depression.

10. Debt-Deflation (Fisher)

    •   (1933): Debt repayment → asset selling & spending cuts → falling prices → economic collapse.