Previous

How successful was the New Deal?

     

Successes

1. Relief

    •  Millions benefited from relief, jobs, and mortgage support via Alphabet Agencies.

2. Roads and building work

    •  PWA & TVA built vital (roads, airports, schools, dams, etc.).

3. Reform

    •  New laws (Social Security, Minimum Wage, Trade Unions) improved rights and conditions for workers.

    •  Native Americans benefited from the (1934), which stopped land losses, supported self-governance, and promoted cultural/economic devl.

    •  No civil rights laws passed, but the (incl. Mary McLeod Bethune) gave advice to govt.

4. Restored faith in democracy

    •  Preserved democracy in the USA (cf. Italy/Germany).

    •  Redefined govt’s role in helping citizens.

    •  Influenced future policies, eg the British Welfare State (1948).

    •  Eleanor Roosevelt’s work helped draft the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

5. Roosevelt

    •  Admired as a heroic leader, elected four times. Even critics acknowledge his lasting impact.

 

Weaknesses and Failings

1. Did not end the Depression

    •  Policies (balanced budget, sound money) ≠ solve Depression.

    •  By 1935 he had failed to end – fell to 7.7m by 1937 but rose to 10.4m in 1938 after govt cut spending.

    •  The Depression only ended with WWII.

2. Damaged/did not help minority groups

    •  Civil Rights not addressed; did not overrule discriminatory State Jim Crow laws.

    •  AAA policies → job losses for unskilled Black workers in the South.

    •  NRA allowed and CCC camps segregated.

    •   was not extended to agricultural/domestic workers, which barred 55% of African American workers & 87% of wage-earning African American women from benefits.

    •  Mexican continued to 1937; Latino workers excluded from NLRA protections.

3. Determined Opposition

a. Businessmen opposed worker protections & govt interference; eg Henry Ford attacked trade unionists.

b. Republicans criticized wasteful spending (eg ""); blocked New Deal laws post-1938.

c. Activists (eg ’s "Share the Wealth" & ’s pension scheme) claimed reforms ≠ go far enough.

d. State govts accused federal govt of taking their powers.

e. S struck down NRA & AAA, arguing they infringed state powers.

    •  In 1937, Roosevelt proposed forcing old judges to retire & adding new ones, he was accused of trying to 'pack' the Court & becoming a .

    •  Crisis ended when the Court reversed its decisions.