Changes under Mao – II: The Great Leap 1958-62
|
|
Summary In 1958, for reasons which are still debated, Mao decided to push the pace of change much harder, and introduced the 'Great Leap Forward' – an economic revolution based on the peasants. It was a disaster. |
Links:
The Great Leap: • Photos (sanitised) from the time
• The Great Famine - a personal account
• Chinese posters
• A 5-part BBC documentary (scroll down to the Great Leap)
|
|
|
Features of The Great Leap Forward |
|
a. Lift-off |
|
Mao wanted to ‘overtake the capitalist countries in a short time and become the most advanced, powerful country in the world’ |
|
b. Collectivisation |
|
Collectivisation would feed the industrial workers in the towns and produce a cash crop for export |
|
c. The second Five-Year Plan |
|
An ambitious set of industrial targets |
|
d. Blue ants |
|
Mao believed that his targets could be achieved by ‘people’s hearts and minds’, and by mass labour |
|
e. 'Learn from Dazhai' |
|
|
|
The second Five-Year Plan, 1958-62: facts |
|
a. Industrialisation of the countryside |
|
Industrialisation was to be achieved, not in the towns, but in each commune (e.g. backyard furnaces) |
|
b. Self-sufficient Communes |
|
The commune was supposed to provide its families with all they needed, including hospitals and schools; in some places people handed over all their possessions and went to live in ‘habitation centres’ |
|
c. Backyard furnaces |
|
|
|
d. State-owned Enterprises |
|
Private firms and joint state-private enterprises were taken over by the government |
|
e. Targets and lies |
|
State-controlled targets were set, and constantly revised upwards; none of these targets were achieved, but officials constantly claimed they had been exceeded |
|
The second Five-Year Plan, 1958-62: failures |
|
a. Industrial output halved |
|
Output fell – 1958-62 the output of coal fell from 230million tonnes to 180million, the output of light industry fell by 30%, of heavy industry by 65% |
|
b. Quality reduced |
|
Quickly rushed-out goods fell apart |
|
c. Backyard furnaces |
|
The steel produced in the peasant furnaces was simply buried – it was unusable; meanwhile, the peasants had used their pots and tools, and cut down huge swathes of forest to make it (= a personal and an environmental disaster) |
|
d. Rural terror |
|
Terrified officials tried to bully the peasants to produce more. Anybody who tried to carry on with the old ways was a ‘rightist’ and imprisoned. Millions were sent to the Laogai (prison camps) |
|
e. Three Bitter Years, 1959-61 |
|
The result was widespread famine which killed perhaps 30 million Chinese |
|
Why did the Great Leap Forward fail? |
|
a. Manpower not investment |
|
Mao’s belief that human willpower alone could bring economic growth was wrong |
|
b. Targets not techniques |
|
There was no planning – simply targets were issued without any advice about how to achieve them |
|
c. Propaganda not statistics |
|
Nobody dared contradict Mao or admit failure. Anyone who questioned success was denounced as a ‘bourgeois reactionary’. There were no accurate inspections and reports – instead officials simply made up ever-bigger lies |
|
d. Drought and floods |
|
The huge Yangzi River dried up in 1960, but that same year there were devastating floods in the south |
|
e. Soviet withdrawal |
|
In 1960, Mao quarrelled with Khrushchev, as a result of which the Soviet experts were recalled – half of China’s Soviet-run industrial plants had to close down |
|
The famine of 1958-62: facts |
|
a. 30 million deaths |
|
i.e. in the 'Three Bitter Years' of 1959-61 (Central China was worst-hit) |
|
b. Tibet |
|
Tibet was particularly badly hit because – as the Panchen Lama discovered in 1962 – the PRC was guilty of intentional genocide, forbidding the Tibetans to grow grain or move their yak herds |
|
c. Martial law, 1962 |
|
Fearing mass revolution, the government imposed martial law in 1962 |
|
d. Cannibalism |
|
People fought for and stole food. Starving peasants sold, and (it was said) even ate, their children |
|
e. Official denial |
|
Anybody who spoke of famine was declared to a traitor |
|
Task Study this poster (it will help you answer question 1 if you do a google image search to find photographs of the Great Leap Forward for comparison), and write answers to the questions which follow: Propaganda poster, The Great Leap, c.1960 How accurate a picture of the Great Leap Forward does this poster convey? Describe the 'Three Bitter Years' of 1959-61. Explain why the 'Great Leap' failed. |